Sean Duffy says America’s air traffic control communications still use 1980s copper phone lines
The transportation secretary’s pitch for a $31.5 billion rebuild came with one very Googleable image: the skies running on rotary-phone-era wiring.
Listen on YouTube · Spotify · Apple Podcasts
WATCH NOW↓ Sean Duffy told The Shawn Ryan Show that America’s air traffic control communications still rely on copper phone lines from the 1980s, and that even new fiber has to be slowed down so old equipment can handle it. Duffy said the system needs a $31.5 billion rebuild that Congress has now been asked to fund.
No one wants to imagine a jetliner being guided by the technological ghost of a beige kitchen wall phone. That is why this claim works. It is not the usual Washington fog machine of “modernization” and “investment.” It is a brutally simple picture: the sky is full of planes, and the pipes underneath the system sound like they belong in a RadioShack clearance bin.
Sean Duffy, President Trump’s transportation secretary, described arriving at the Department of Transportation into immediate chaos. He said the DCA crash happened on his first full day, followed by a business jet crash in Philadelphia, a NOTAM outage, and other crashes in Arizona, Alaska, and Toronto. Then came the line every new boss loves and every voter should treat with tongs: “I just got here.” Fair. Also convenient.
The rotary phone detail is the scandal
The copper-wire claim is the piece worth separating from the blame game. The Federal Aviation Administration’s aging technology has been a known sore spot for years, and Duffy’s version lands because it gives the problem a household object. Not “legacy systems.” Not “deferred maintenance.” Copper wires. The stuff your parents used to call Blockbuster.
those copper wires that we used in the 80s to call people is the infrastructure we use for our communication system in air traffic control
Duffy’s next detail was even more damning. He said replacing copper with fiber is not a clean swap, because the equipment on either end is also old. In other words, you can install the fast road, but the cars are still Model Ts.
we have to slow down the fiber ratchet it down to make the equipment think that it’s still running on copper
That is the part that should stick. A modernized cable is only as good as the radios, switches, software, towers, and control centers attached to it. Duffy said the system needs “new everything,” which sounds like exaggeration until he starts listing the chain: airport towers, TRACONs that manage airspace around airports, and en route centers that cover the country.
The $31.5 billion ask, and the blame
Duffy said he asked Congress for $31.5 billion, with about $12 billion for buildings and physical facilities. That is the sober part of the pitch. The less sober part is his claim that “mismanagement from the last four years” suddenly “came to fruition” right when he walked in the door. Please. Air traffic control decay is not a four-year hangover. It is the kind of slow civic rot that survives administrations, press conferences, blue-ribbon reports, and several generations of people promising to fix it after the next budget cycle.
I have I’ve asked for 31 and a half billion.
Still, Duffy’s self-interest does not make the infrastructure warning fake. The strongest version of his argument is not partisan. It is operational. Air traffic control is not a website that can go dark for an hour while someone pushes a patch. It is a live safety system, which is why replacing it is maddeningly hard. You have to rebuild the machine while the machine is still flying the planes.
That is also why this is a better podcast moment than a stump speech. Shawn Ryan keeps pushing the practical question: why not just build new towers? Duffy’s answer is money, line of sight, available locations, and the ugly fact that thousands of facilities cannot all be replaced at once. The boring answer is the real one. America did not end up with old transportation infrastructure because nobody noticed. It ended up here because fixing it is expensive, invisible when it works, and politically unrewarding until something breaks.
these systems can’t go down because I have planes in the air that rely on that system.
- What did Sean Duffy say about air traffic control?
- Sean Duffy said America’s air traffic control communications still rely on copper phone lines from the 1980s. He also said that when fiber is installed, parts of the system have to be slowed down so older equipment can still function.
- How much money did Sean Duffy say he requested for air traffic control?
- Duffy said he asked for $31.5 billion, with roughly $12 billion going toward physical facilities such as towers, TRACONs, and en route centers. His argument was that the whole system cannot be rebuilt at once, so the oldest and most urgent pieces have to come first.
- Did Sean Duffy blame the previous administration for aviation problems?
- Yes. Duffy said he thought “mismanagement from the last four years” came due just as he arrived, after a cluster of crashes and system failures. That part is the political sales pitch, and it is less convincing than his concrete description of old wiring, old equipment, and a shortage of controllers.
The circuit, read weekly. No noise.